Member-only story
The Era of Corporate DEI Cognitive Dissonance: When Leaders Say One Thing and Do Another
In today’s polarized environment, corporate leaders are increasingly navigating a paradox: publicly committing to diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives while simultaneously retreating in the face of mounting attacks from far-right pundits. These critics often seek to marginalize DEI efforts, positioning them as antithetical to American values or corporate profitability. The result is a growing cognitive dissonance, where leaders champion inclusion in their speeches and press releases but fail to sustain those commitments when challenged.
This paradox is particularly evident when corporate leaders fall prey to external pressures, such as political or financial threats. These forces often come from individuals or groups who misunderstand or oppose the true purpose of DEI. For example, right-wing commentators regularly frame DEI efforts as divisive, arguing that they erode merit-based systems or unfairly prioritize certain groups over others. In response, companies find themselves caught in the crossfire between a desire to uphold their public commitments to inclusion and the pressures of maintaining shareholder confidence, managing customer backlash, or avoiding public controversy.
